Methodology

How our grades work

One 0–100 grade per player, ranked against players at the same position in the same league. 6% of graded players are at 90 or higher and the median is 59. Every grade shows the plays and games behind it.

The method

Production, not reputation.

  1. Start from the play. Every grade is built from public play-by-play: what each play was worth to the offense, adjusted for the opponent, the down and the field position. Nothing comes from a highlight reel, a recruiting ranking or a team’s name.
  2. Credit the player named on the play. A passer, ball carrier or target is credited for the plays he was named on. Defenders are graded per team game on stops, disruptive plays and tackles (NFL snap counts are shown beside the grade, not used in it), with sacks and hurries weighted up front and breakups and interceptions weighted in coverage.
  3. Weight what the role is for. Each position has its own measures and weights. The weights are on the methodology page.
  4. Pull small samples toward the middle. A player is graded only once he clears the minimum for his position. Above it, every number is pulled toward the position average until his sample earns its place, so a short hot streak never outranks a full season.
  5. Rank inside the position. A grade is a 0–100 score placed against the players graded at the same position in the same league: 6% of graded players are at 90 or higher, 20% are at 80 or higher, and the median is 59. A 75 means the same thing for a safety and a receiver.

What it is, and is not

A record of what a player produced.

A grade describes production to date. It is not a forecast of what a player will do next, and it does not replace film. College play-by-play has no snap counts and no free source records who was on the field. NFL snap counts come from Pro Football Reference via nflverse, and an NFL running back is credited for his share of his team’s offensive snaps. An NFL wide receiver or tight end has his own grade, described below. No source we use records routes or coverage assignments, so a defender’s grade is production (tackles, stops, disruptive plays), not coverage or technique.

Share is a player’s part of his team’s season. It divides his counted dropbacks, carries or targets (for a defender, his plays made per 100 plays his defense faced) by everything his team did across every game it has played, with garbage time out as in the grades. A game he missed lowers it. College play-by-play does not record who was on the field, so college Share counts plays, not snaps.

The client portal’s Stats view ranks every player by every number on his profile, one position group at a time. Season totals are official statistics (CollegeFootballData for college, nflverse for the NFL); success, points added, stops and share are counted from play-by-play, so they can differ slightly from an official line. A rate is ranked only at a minimum: the grade’s own where it has one, 20 punts for punters, 10 returns for returners. Kickers’ rates are listed and never ranked. Counting stats rank everyone, and equal values share a rank.

NFL wide receivers and tight ends

The grade measures how much scoring value a receiver creates per team game from his own production: the expected points added on his targets and any carries, adjusted for the pass defenses he faced, with his playing time counted. The weights on his statistics (target share, success, yards and depth per target, yards after the catch, drops, contested and created catches, snap share and others) were learned from the 2023, 2024 and 2025 seasons by predicting how receivers produced in games the model had not seen; none were set by hand, and no other company’s grades or rankings were used. For a receiver with few targets the grade also leans on where he was drafted and his previous season, a weight that fades as his own targets accumulate. Grades use the same 0–100 scale as every other grade and appear only from 25 targets over 4 games. In tests on games held out of the fit, a receiver’s grade from one stretch of games had a correlation of about 0.4 with his production in the next stretch (wide receivers 0.40, tight ends 0.37 on average over eight tests; individual tests ran from about 0.2 to 0.6). A correlation of 0.4 is a tendency across a group of receivers, not a prediction for any one player or game: most of what a receiver produces next is not explained by his grade. It is a production grade; it does not measure route running, separation or blocking. Includes charting data: FTN Data via nflverse (CC BY-SA 4.0).

Below the sample rule a player shows his counts and no grade. Every rate carries its count.

Positions

Where a grade exists.

Ranked: quarterbacks, running backs, wide receivers, NFL tight ends, EDGE rushers, interior linemen, linebackers, cornerbacks, safeties, punters and returners, each inside his own position and league. A player below the sample rule, college tight ends and kickers show counts and no grade: a kicker’s grade did not repeat from one half-season to the next, so his field goals by distance, extra points and kickoffs are listed with their counts. Cornerback grades repeat the least from half to half (see the stability numbers below), so read them as production to date.

Why offensive linemen are not graded

Play-by-play never names a blocker. A grade for a lineman would be a guess with a number on it, so his page shows what the record does hold: his line’s pass protection and run blocking against every line in his league, shared by the whole line, and his own penalties. A grade charted from film can replace that view when a staff provides the film.

Backtest: 2025 honors

Did the grades find the players the sport honored?

We graded the 2025 season and asked where the players on the 2025 honors lists landed at their position. Same lists, earlier method against the current one. Counts are players we could grade, each player counted once.

2025 honorees: earlier method against the current method
GroupEarlier methodCurrent method
NFL, all positions, top 10 at position 2025 All-Pro and Pro Bowl31 of 7640 of 78
NFL, all positions, top 25 at position55 of 7660 of 78
FBS offense, top 10 at position 2025 All-America and major awards8 of 2011 of 20
FBS offense, top 25 at position16 of 2017 of 20
NFL defense, top tenth of class14 of 4425 of 46
FBS defense, top tenth of class3 of 1915 of 22

The two NFL top-10 and top-25 rows were measured before the Nov 13 receiver update, when NFL wide receivers and tight ends moved to a new grade; they have not been rerun on it.

FBS defense: no 2025 FBS defender play data exists, so the earlier figure is a proxy on the same inputs. FCS defenders could not be tested: the 2025 FCS defensive data is too sparse. FCS offensive players could not be tested.

Stability

Do grades repeat from one half of a season to the next?

We graded each player on the first half of the season and again on the second, then measured how closely the two rankings agree (rank correlation: 1.0 is the same order, 0 is no agreement).

.425

FBS

1,170 players graded in both halves.

.487

FCS

908 players graded in both halves.

.473

NFL

289 players graded in both halves.

0.46

NFL defenders

Earlier method 0.39. Cornerbacks 0.27 (earlier 0.17), which is thin; EDGE rushers 0.54; linebackers 0.62. 2026 weeks 1–4 against 5–9.

A grade is a record, not a projection: two half-season grades agree only loosely, so every profile carries the game log and the plays behind the grade. The NFL figures rest on far fewer games than the college figures.

Accuracy

Every stat line checked against the official data.

34,226 player profiles, 0 mismatches. This build read back every profile (16,330 FBS, 14,739 FCS, 3,157 NFL) from its data file: the player is there and carries the grade the rankings show. On November 10, 2026, 34,086 player pages (16,281 FBS, 14,674 FCS, 3,131 NFL) were also opened in a browser and compared with the official season totals from CollegeFootballData.com and nflverse: 0 mismatches.

Data credits

Where the data comes from.

College play-by-play: CollegeFootballData.com. NFL play-by-play: nflverse (CC BY 4.0). NFL charting: FTN Data via nflverse (CC BY-SA 4.0). Grades, ranks and notes are MacKool’s own work. Updated November 16, 2026.

We’re booking staffs for this season and 2027.

Name the opponent and the game date. We build the plan from public play-by-play and send it to your staff email.